A toxic employee doesn’t become less toxic just because they’re a high performer.

This is one of the easiest exceptions for leaders to make. Someone brings in revenue, has rare expertise, or consistently delivers under pressure, so the organization starts treating their behavior as a separate issue.

They’re abrasive, but brilliant. Difficult, but indispensable. The problem is that the rest of the team is still absorbing the cost.

Coworkers spend time recovering from interactions with them, avoiding them, working around them, or withholding concerns because they don’t want the confrontation.

Managers have to spend time repairing the damage, and good employees may eventually decide the environment isn’t worth it.

The high performer keeps producing visible results while the damage they create remains scattered across everyone else. That’s why performance can’t be evaluated in isolation from impact.

The question isn’t only, “What does this person contribute?” It’s also, “What does it cost the rest of the organization to keep getting that contribution?”

Some difficult employees really are worth coaching and developing, but strong results shouldn’t become permission to behave in ways that would be unacceptable from anyone else.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply