Some leaders win the point and lose the person.
The manager proves they were right and gets the employee to agree, but the employee leaves less willing to speak openly next time.
That’s an expensive victory.
A leader can reach the right conclusion in a way that makes future disagreement harder. The employee may still comply, but they start withholding concerns or waiting until they are certain before challenging anything.
Now the manager has fewer arguments, but they also have less honesty.
This is why I think the quality of a disagreement should be judged by more than whether the issue was settled. It’s also what happened to the relationship afterward and whether the employee believes they can disagree again without feeling that they’re risking status, trust, or access.
None of this means managers should avoid firm decisions or make every disagreement pleasant. Sometimes a manager needs to make the call, and the employee will be disappointed, but there’s a difference between disappointing someone and teaching them that disagreement is dangerous.
The goal isn’t to make sure nobody leaves uncomfortable. It’s to resolve the issue in a way that the relationship remains strong enough to carry another disagreement later.
References: Bodin AM. The interactional view: Family therapy approaches of the MRI In AS, Gurman, P. Handbook of Family Therapy. Published online 1981.
